Over the holidays I cracked open a bottle of Laphroaig Select single malt Scotch whisky. Created around 2010, this expression takes classic Laphroaig DNA, peated spirit matured in ex-bourbon barrels, and blends it with whisky that has spent time in a variety of other casks.
The distillery team created six different cask-influenced versions, and the final recipe was chosen by the brand’s fan community, Friends of Laphroaig. The result? A milder, more accessible take on one of Islay’s most famously divisive distilleries.
The Laphroaig Select is a marriage of spirit matured in American Oak, first-fill bourbon barrels, Pedro Ximénez hogsheads, and Oloroso sherry butts. An ambitious mix for a non-age-statement release.
In 2023, it received a packaging refresh. It is now known in markets as Laphroaig Oak Select, though the recipe remains unchanged. You’ll often find it in the affordable price bracket on Amazon. This makes it an easy bottle to pick up if you’re peat-curious but not ready to dive headfirst into Laphroaig’s heavier expressions.
A Brief History of the Distillery
Laphroaig was founded in 1815 by brothers Donald and Alexander Johnston on the rugged Isle of Islay. Laphroaig has long been synonymous with bold, smoky, medicinal whisky. Originally a side venture to their cattle business, the distillery remained in the Johnston family until 1954.
When Ian Hunter, the last of the lineage, passed away, he left the distillery to his secretary and manager, the legendary Bessie Williamson. She became the first woman to run a Scotch distillery in the 20th century and played a major role in turning Laphroaig into the powerhouse it is today.
Today, the distillery sits under the umbrella of Suntory Global Spirits, joining a portfolio that includes Yamazaki, Bowmore, Chita, Jim Beam and Maker’s Mark.
Also Read: Laphroaig 10 vs Quarter Cask Whisky
Tasting Notes: Laphroaig Select Single Malt Whisky
ABV: 43%
REGION: Islay
COLOUR: Gold
NOSE: Classic Laphroaig, but noticeably calmer and sweeter. Expect gentle peat smoke, iodine, damp earth, and soft ash wrapped in vanilla, caramel, and honey. There’s also a touch of fresh fruit with a sprinkle of sea salt.
PALATE: The palate delivers soft vanilla-sugar sweetness, mild peat, and an easygoing smokiness. Hints of orange juice, ginger, cinnamon, and black pepper add lift, while something slightly herbal lingers in the background.
There’s also a pastry-like note, almost like warm almond croissants with a faint coastal saltiness. Medium-bodied with a touch of alcohol heat. A splash of water smooths out the alcohol but mutes the peat and sweetness, bringing forward more bitter lemon and pepper.
FINISH: Medium in length, ending with earthy peat, subtle spice, and lemon zest.
RATING: VERY GOOD
The Laphroaig Select whisky is designed to be approachable, and in that respect, it absolutely succeeds. It highlights the distillery’s trademark medicinal character in a toned-down, user-friendly way. It is perfect for newcomers who want to dip their toes into Islay without being overwhelmed.
For seasoned peat lovers, however, this release may feel too polite. Laphroaig is known for whisky that hits you square in the face with bold flavours and forces you to choose a side. Laphroaig Select, by comparison, is softer, cleaner, and more restrained.
The variety of cask types adds complexity, but not always cohesion. The dram sometimes feels caught between sweet fruity influence and smoky medicinal intensity, without fully committing to either.
Who Is Laphroaig Select Whisky For?
For the price point and accessibility, it remains a solid bottle. If you’re exploring the Laphroaig range, or want an easy-drinking smoky whisky for casual evenings, Laphroaig Select (or as it is now called, the Laphroaig Oak Select) is a great starting point. But if you’re chasing the full power of Islay peat, you’ll probably be reaching for the 10 year old soon after your glass is empty.
Also Read: Laphroaig Whisky and Stilton Cheese Pairing
Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I may receive a commission if you click on a link and make a purchase.