Tag: Rating: Very Good Page 4 of 21

Whisky of the Week review and tasting notes for whisky I rated Very Good. When the dram is enjoyable and memorable, and we don’t mind having another glass later in the week. This is bottles I might use for cocktails and the occasional afternoon sipper. Rating: Very Good

Auchentoshan American Oak Whisky

By Jeannette Wentzel

On 01/30/2023

In Single Malt whisky

I have not tried an Auchentoshan whisky in years. I loved the Heartwood release, and our bottle did not last very long. A couple of years ago, I bought the Auchentoshan American Oak single malt Scotch whisky but left it standing in the cupboard until last week when I was looking for something new to try.

Auchentoshan distillery is a single malt whisky distillery located at the foot of the Kilpatrick Hills on the outskirts of Clydebank in West Dunbartonshire, just northwest of the city of Glasgow.

The name is from Gaelic, ‘Achadh an Oisein’ and translates as “corner of the field”. It is one of six malt whisky distilleries in the Scottish Lowlands, along with Glenkinchie, Bladnoch and Ailsa Bay.

Also Read: Dunville’s PX Cask 12 yo Whiskey

The distillery has changed hands many times since it opened in 1823. It is now part of the Beam Suntory portfolio. Unusually, all of its production is used for single malt, and they still triple distil all the whisky.

The standard range of Auchentoshan whisky is quite extensive and includes an Auchentoshan 12 yo, Three Wood and even a Blood Oak release (aged in bourbon and red wine casks). The Auchentoshan distillery character is described as smooth and calm.

The Auchentoshan American Oak whisky is their entry-level bottling and aged entirely in first fill ex-bourbon casks. It was first released in 2014 as a replacement for the Classic expression.

Auchentoshan American Oak Whisky Review

REGION: Lowland

ABV: 43%

COLOUR: Pale gold

NOSE: Gentle creamy sweetness with wood and vanilla. Bits of orange flowers and tropical fruit mixed with malt. Sweet and gentle.

PALATE: Creamy cereal, warming oak and honey with bits of vanilla and soft oak spices. Quite sweet with faint lemon notes. Medium body, nice and smooth. Water softens the palate, making it less complex and dampening the oak and spicy notes. It is better without water.

FINISH: Shortish with notes of oak, lemon peel and honey.

RATING: VERY GOOD

The Auchentoshan American Oak whisky is a very affordable single malt at a retail price of R410 in South Africa. It is sweet with lovely warming oak notes and makes a beautiful pre-dinner dram.

You don’t need to add water; the triple distilling ensures a smooth, light experience. Not the most complex dram.

It is a NAS release and the whisky retails for around R410 in South Africa and around £30 in the UK.But at the price point, it is good value for money.

Also Read: Dewars White Label Whisky

Lagavulin 16 year old Whisky

By Jeannette Wentzel

On 12/26/2022

In Single Malt whisky

If you know about peaty whisky, the name “Lagavulin 16 year old” is bound to cross your path. This single malt whisky has become a cult classic, often serving as the measuring stick for Islay peatiness.

It’s a perennial favourite among many of my whisky-loving friends, and today, I am delving into the intriguing world of Lagavulin 16 year old Islay single malt Scotch whisky.

Lagavulin 16 yo whisky, a cornerstone of the Islay scene, has long been celebrated for its distinctive character. My journey into the Lagavulin universe began with the Distillers Edition. Now, it’s time to acquaint myself with its iconic 16 yo counterpart.

Lagavulin is a historic distillery with centuries-old roots, situated in a picturesque bay along Islay’s south coast. The name “Lagavulin” translates from Gaelic to “Lag a’ Mhuilinn,” signifying the hollow of the mill.

Founded by local farmer John Johnston in 1816, it stands proudly within sight of Dunyvaig Castle. However, illicit distillation has been a covert art in these parts for much longer. For a deeper dive into Lagavulin’s rich history, check out the details in my Distillers Edition blog post.

Among Diageo’s “Classic Malts of Scotland,” a prestigious lineup with Cragganmore, Dalwhinnie, Glenkinchie, Oban, and Talisker, Lagavulin holds its own distinctive place. This distinction can be attributed to its meticulous distillation process involving slow distillation speeds and pear-shaped pot stills.

Lagavulin offers various expressions, including the Lagavulin 8 year old, the different Distillers Editions, luxurious 25 year old and 30 year old bottlings, and regular 12 year old releases. The Lagavulin 16 year old single malt whisky was aged in oak barrels and boasts a peat level of approximately 35 ppm.

Also Read: Tamnavulin Double Cask Whisky

Lagavulin 16 year old Whisky Review

REGION: Islay

ABV: 43%

COLOUR: Dark gold

NOSE: The nose has notes of liquorice, smoke, subtle hints of peat, and tantalizing fruity sweetness. Oak, iodine, and vanilla notes dance delicately in the background, creating a beautifully balanced olfactory experience.

PALATE: Dry oak and peat form the backbone, complemented by a gentle cherry sweetness and wisps of smoke. The medium body carries traces of iodine and tar. It is not very complex and somewhat one-dimensional.

FINISH: Lagavulin 16 year old whisky leaves you with a medium-length finish with lingering peatiness, hints of oak, and a touch of vanilla.

RATING: VERY GOOD

We exchanged slightly disappointed glances as I shared this Lagavulin moment with John. Our anticipation was high, yet the experience didn’t match the hype. While undoubtedly peaty with its signature smokiness and fruity undertones, Lagavulin 16 year old single malt lacked the depth and wow factor we had hoped for.

It displayed a few rough edges and didn’t quite live up to the impeccable balance promised by its nose. This particular bottle might be in my collection for an extended period.

The Lagavulin 16 year old Scotch is one of those whiskies that begs to be paired with a robust cheese. Imagine the intense flavours of Blue Stilton or Roquefort cheese intermingling with the peaty nuances of this Islay classic. It is a match made in heaven for any connoisseur.

In my ongoing series of side-by-side comparisons, I’ve ventured into a Lagavulin versus Ardbeg 10 yo whisky comparison as well as an Uigeadail versus Lagaulin comparison. Are you curious to see how these titans of Islay measure up against each other? Dive into the world of peat and flavour with my detailed analysis.

As you venture forth on your whisky journey, remember that Lagavulin 16 year old whisky is an essential stop on discovering the rich, smoky wonders of Islay single malt.

Whether it completely sweeps you off your feet or not, its legendary status is undeniable, making it an experience every whisky enthusiast should undertake.

Also Read: Loch Lomond Steam and Fire Whisky

GlenDronach Peated Whisky

By Jeannette Wentzel

On 11/07/2022

In Single Malt whisky

I have tried at least one GlenDronach each year for the last three years, and in 2022 I want to continue this streak. So this year, I chose a peated release from this typical sherry forward distillery; the GlenDronach Peated single malt Scotch whisky.

I love the GlenDronach 18 year old and rated it, Divine. It is a perfect example of all that is delicious in sherry forward whisky from Speyside. The GlenDronach 21 year old is good, but not as nice as the 18 year old. Other releases in the core range include the 12 year old and the GlenDronach 15 year old.

James Allardice founded the GlenDronach Distillery Company in Forgue, near Huntly. The distillery was damaged in a fire in 1837, and five years later, Allardice went bankrupt. It was bought and rebuilt, and various well-known companies owned the distillery during the following 120 years.

Also Read: Black Bottle Whisky

During the 60s, it passed on to William Teacher & Sons, and they expanded the production. In 1996 it was mothballed, and through a series of mergers and acquisitions, the distillery ended up with French Pernod Ricard in 2005. They sold it to the BenRiach Distilling Co. in 2008. In 2016, the distillery changed hands again, this time going to the US distiller Brown-Forman.

GlenDronach introduced the Peated edition in 2015. It is made using lightly peated barley. First matured in ex-bourbon casks and then finished in Oloroso and Pedro Ximenez sherry casks. The GlenDronach Peated is not chill-filtered and is a NAS release. The spirit is peated to around 25ppm. Similar to Paul John Bold and Talisker Skye.

GlenDronach Peated Whisky Review

REGION: Speyside

ABV: 46%

COLOUR: Dark amber

NOSE: Soft peat, toasted wood, oak spices and fruity sweetness. I was hoping for some of the sherry and fruity red notes to come through, but the fruit notes are more baked apple and orange flavours. Bits of raisins, vanilla and cinnamon.

PALATE: Soft, elegant peat with woody notes. Bits of honey sweetness, roasted pear, nuts and cinnamon. Chewy and bold but still drinkable. Oak spices and pepper.

Water softens the peat a bit and brings more malt to the front. Medium body but not as complex and smooth as the 18 yo. Again I was looking for the sherry notes, but it is negligible.

FINISH: Medium length with notes of smoky wood, oak spices and honey.

RATING: VERY GOOD

I was hoping that more of the delicious red Oloroso sherry notes would come through, but the fruit profile was more ripe green than red fruit. The peat is not the fishy, medicinal Islay peat, but a more heather and dried earth kind of peat.

I love the GlenDronach 12 year old and was hoping it would be a bit more of a sherry bomb integrated with peaty notes, similar to the Laphroaig PX cask, but the Peated is not that.

Not quite sherried enough and not quite the right peat. A Jack of all trades but a master of none comes to mind. It is a lovely release but doesn’t quite tick the sherry or peat boxes. I will stick to the unpeated releases from this distillery and pour me a glass of the Glendronach 12 year old.

The GlenDronach Peated single malt Scotch retail for around R 1 000 in South Africa and I have seen some recently at Bottega Whiskey.

Also Read: Dunville’s Three Crowns Peated Whiskey

Johnnie Walker Black Label Sherry Finish Whisky

By Jeannette Wentzel

On 10/17/2022

In Blended whisky

On my recent trip to Mauritius, I found an interesting bottle of Johnnie Walker whisky in the supermarket. I had not seen the Johnnie Walker Black Label Sherry Finish blended Scotch whisky before and bought a bottle to try.

On the island, we had some time to explore this bottle properly. We love the Black Label whisky and always have a bottle around. So it made sense to spend a bit of time with this bottle.

The Sherry Finish is a limited edition Johnnie Walker Black Label initially released as a Taiwan exclusive. It is now available in more countries. According to the brand, this release combines the familiar notes of the Black Label whisky with dried plum and fig with aromatic vanilla.

Also Read: The Singleton Tailfire Whisky

Like the standard Black Label, the Sherry Finish is a blend that includes whisky from Cardhu in Speyside, Cameronbridge and Glenkinchie in the Lowlands and Clynelish from the Scottish Highlands. It was aged for 12 years and then finished in barrels seasoned with sherry from Jerez.

Johnnie Walker Black Label Sherry Finish Whisky Review

ABV: 40%

COLOUR: Reddish gold

NOSE: It has the distinctive Black Label peat and smoky nose with an extra layer of sweetness. Red fruits, dried cherries and hints of sherry. Bits of spice and vanilla, with hints of dry wood.

PALATE: Peat and faint sherry sweetness with black pepper, red berries and caramel. Drying tannins and oak underlay the red fruits with hints of chocolate. On the palate, it is delicate and soft with none of the standard Black Label bolder notes. As the ABV was only 40%, we did not add water.

FINISH: A drying, peaty finish with bitter citrus and black pepper. Medium length.

RATING: VERY GOOD

I was expecting a bit more of the sherry richness to shine through. The sherry notes are subdued and somewhat out of balance with the peat and spices. The sherry finish adds a unique red fruit note but also tannins and drying oak.

Not bad, but if I have to choose between the Sherry Finish or the standard Black Label, I will take the standard Black Label whisky. I have to add that we quickly finished our bottle during our holiday. It will be a great dram for Johnnie Walker aficionados.

The serving suggestion for the Sherry Finish whisky is either on the rocks or in a tall glass filled with ice, topped up with a blackcurrant mixer and garnished with a sprig of mint or a slice of citrus. According to Johnnie Walker, it also pairs well with dark fruits, nuts and chocolate after a meal.

I have not seen it in South Africa, and I can’t remember what we paid for it in Mauritius. It was not too expensive, though; I see it retails for around R 650 worldwide. On Amazon you can pick it up for £33.

Also Read: Johnnie Walker Select Casks Rye Finish Whisky

Wemyss Peat Chimney Whisky

By Jeannette Wentzel

On 10/03/2022

In Blended Malt Whisky

I have been looking through my whisky cupboard, trying to find something new to drink, a dram standing around too long that needs some attention. Something interesting for me to write about. I am a huge Wemyss Malts fan, so let’s explore the Peat Chimney blended malt whisky today.

I especially appreciate the Single Cask releases from this innovative bottler. They always come up with wonderfully descriptive names for the bottlings, naming the releases after a “distinct taste profile”.

I have Lemon Sorbet and Peppered Biltong in my collection. How delicious does that sound! Some of the new releases include ‘Jam on Toast’ and ‘Cherry Bakewell Pie’.

Also Read: Mackinlay’s Whisky

Wemyss Malts was founded in 2005, and it has been independently run by brother and sister duo William and Isabella, who are family of the Scottish Wemyss family. There are three blended malts released in the series, as well as batch strength versions. They include The Hive and Spice King. They usually are available in SA and retail for around R850.

Peat Chimney is a blended malt containing more than 10 single malts, with the signature malt coming from Islay to bring elegant notes of sweet smoke, salt and peat. Peat Chimney was launched in 2005. It is non-chill-filtered and bottled at 46%, same as all the Wemyss releases.

Wemyss Malts Peat Chimney Whisky Review

ABV: 46%

COLOUR: Dark gold

NOSE: Light and elegant smoke, bits of peat mixed with some sweet fruit. Creamy cereal and salty notes with hints of stewed prunes.

PALATE: Stewed apple, bits of spice and hints of smoke and earthy peat. Caramel sweetness, green notes and hints of pepper and malt. Medium body. Add water carefully. Just a drop or two to release more fruity sweetness. If you add too much, it drowns out any smoke.

FINISH: Medium length with fruity sweetness and citrus.

RATING: VERY GOOD

The Wemyss Peat Chimney has a nice balance between fruity sweetness, smoke and peat. It is a gentle introduction for anyone who wants to explore peat and smoke.

I was hoping for a bolder mouthfeel and something with a bit more character. But that might be because I have been trying bold peaty drams this year that I was expecting something more memorable.

That is just me. The Wemyss Malt Peat Chimney blended malt is not a bad bottle, and we will probably finish it in the not too distant future. I might use this as a base to blend with other Islay malts to see if I can brighten it up.

Also Read: Compass Box No Name No 2 Whisky