It’s time for another side-by-side bourbon showdown. This week, I’m comparing two of Kentucky’s most popular and widely available bourbons: Buffalo Trace vs Woodford Reserve. These bottles regularly appear on recommended bourbon lists, but how do they compare when tasted head-to-head?
As with many of my whisky comparisons, we conducted this tasting blind to remove any brand bias and focus purely on what was in the glass. Blind tastings often reveal surprising results and are one of the best ways to discover what your palate genuinely prefers.
Also Read: Maker’s Mark vs Woodford Reserve
Buffalo Trace Bourbon Whiskey
Produced at the legendary Buffalo Trace Distillery in Frankfort, Kentucky, Buffalo Trace bourbon whiskey was launched in 1999 by the Sazerac Company. Although the bourbon carries no age statement, it has earned a reputation as one of the best-value bourbons on the market.
The exact mash bill remains a closely guarded secret, but bourbon enthusiasts generally believe it contains a high percentage of corn with less than 10% rye. This creates a sweeter, more approachable profile while still delivering enough spice to keep things interesting.
The brand takes its name from the ancient buffalo trails that crossed America as herds migrated westward. These same trails were later followed by pioneers, making the name a tribute to both the buffalo and the spirit of exploration.
Buffalo Trace Distillery is home to some of the most sought-after bourbons in the world, including Blanton’s, Eagle Rare, W.L. Weller and Sazerac Rye. Despite sharing a home with these premium releases, Buffalo Trace remains remarkably affordable and widely available.
Its versatility makes it an excellent choice for sipping neat, enjoying over ice, or mixing into classic bourbon cocktails such as an Old Fashioned.
Woodford Reserve Bourbon Whiskey
Woodford Reserve is produced by Brown-Forman at the historic Woodford Reserve Distillery in Versailles, Kentucky. The site has a long and fascinating history, with Brown-Forman acquiring and restoring the property in 1993 before officially launching Woodford Reserve bourbon in 1996.
The distillery itself is recognised as a National Historic Landmark and remains one of Kentucky’s most picturesque bourbon destinations.
Unlike Buffalo Trace, Woodford Reserve openly shares its mash bill: 72% corn, 18% rye and 10% malted barley. The relatively high rye content adds spice and structure, while malted barley adds depth and complexity.
Woodford Reserve is also somewhat unique in the bourbon world because it is triple distilled and enters the barrel at a lower proof than many competitors. The bourbon is matured for at least six years, allowing it to develop a rich balance of sweetness, spice and oak.
Beyond the flagship bourbon, the Woodford Reserve range includes excellent releases such as Double Oaked and Woodford Reserve Rye.
Woodford Reserve is available in the UK and retail in the affordable category. Other brands in the Brown Forman stable include Jack Daniel’s, GlenDronach, BenRiach and Glenglassaugh whisky.
Buy Woodford Reserve on Amazon
Buffalo Trace vs Woodford Reserve Bourbon
| Buffalo Trace | Woodford Reserve | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Bourbon whiskey | Bourbon whiskey |
| Mashbill | Not disclosed | 72% corn, 18% rye and 10% malt |
| ABV | 45% | 43.2% |
| Colour | A reddish copper | Dark copper |
| Nose | Fruity sweetness, rich and bold. There are hints of candied fruit, caramel, vanilla, brandy pudding and oak. Bits of spice float in the background. | Honey sweetness with apricots and oranges. Bits of condensed milk richness mixed with vanilla, dark chocolate and hints of spices. |
| Palate | There are notes of fruit, orange marmalade, white pepper and oak. Bits of cinnamon with toasted oak. Water tones down the spice. | Oak and sweetness perfectly balanced with apricot and cinnamon spiciness. Tangy winter fruits and vanilla mixed with toffee. Creamy and smooth with a full body and a satisfying mouthfeel. |
| Finish | Before adding water long and ended in notes of spicy sweetness. After adding water, the finish was quite flat. | Long and lingering and ends in notes of sweetness and spices |
| My Rating | Very Good | Excellent |
| Comments | Drink it neat! | Delicious and bold. |
Identifying the Buffalo Trace in the blind tasting proved surprisingly straightforward. While both bourbons share classic notes of vanilla, caramel and oak, Buffalo Trace displayed a noticeably spicier character on the palate, giving it away.
On the nose, Buffalo Trace is bold and expressive. Sweet vanilla dominates, with oak, caramel, brandy pudding, and a touch of baking spice. It immediately feels vibrant and inviting.
The Woodford Reserve takes a slightly different approach. The nose is softer, more refined and noticeably more elegant. Notes of apricot, vanilla, toasted oak, and orange, along with dark chocolate, create a richer aromatic experience that encourages you to linger with the glass.
Once tasted, the differences become even more apparent. The Buffalo Trace delivers a medium-bodied mouthfeel with plenty of vanilla sweetness, orange marmalade and oak. The white pepper spice builds steadily through the palate, creating an enjoyable balance between sweetness and heat.
It is approachable, easy-drinking and highly enjoyable. However, I found that adding water diluted its charm and muted its flavours.
Woodford Reserve offers a creamier texture and greater depth. Rich vanilla, apricots, caramel and dark chocolate notes combine with well-integrated cinnamon spice and winter fruits. The palate feels fuller and more luxurious than the nose initially suggests.
Verdict: Buffalo Trace vs Woodford Reserve
This was an enjoyable comparison between two excellent bourbons that deserve their popularity. If you enjoy a bourbon with a slightly spicier edge, bright fruit notes and exceptional value, Buffalo Trace is a fantastic choice. It is approachable, versatile and easy to recommend to both newcomers and experienced bourbon drinkers.
For my palate, however, Woodford Reserve takes the win. Its creamy texture, richer sweetness and notes of vanilla, chocolate and oak create a more complex and satisfying drinking experience.
The good news is that there is no wrong choice here. Whether you choose Buffalo Trace or Woodford Reserve, you’ll be adding a quality Kentucky bourbon to your collection.
Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I may receive a commission if you click on a link and make a purchase.
Also Read: My Favourite Margarita Recipe
